top of page
  • Writer's pictureCheri Woodsmall

The Cookie Apocalypse: The Impact of Third-Party Cookie Degradation on Commercial Construction Marketing

Yikes! Can you believe 2024 is halfway over? As we move towards 2025, the digital marketing landscape for commercial construction companies will undergo a significant transformation.

Google's decision to phase out third-party cookies in Chrome, now scheduled for 2025, presents both challenges and opportunities for construction firms advertising online. But what does this mean for your business, and why should you be concerned?

(Image Created with DALL-E)

Understanding Cookies in Construction Marketing

We aren't talking about those incredible Chocolate Chip cookies your Grandma Bev made. Cookies are small text files stored on users' devices when they visit websites. These digital tools play a crucial role in enhancing user experience and gathering valuable data. Let's delve deeper into how each type of cookie functions in the construction industry:

First-Party Cookies

Your website creates and stores first-party cookies when a user visits it. They are essential for providing potential clients and partners with a seamless and personalized experience.

Here's how they can benefit your construction marketing:

  • User Preferences: They remember language preferences, ensuring that international clients see your website in their preferred language.

  • Login Information: First-party cookies can keep users logged in for client portals or project management interfaces, streamlining access to project updates and communications.

  • Project Estimates: They can save partially completed project estimate forms, allowing potential clients to return and finish them later without starting over.

  • Site Functionality: First-party cookies enable features like shopping carts for construction supplies or materials ordering systems to function correctly.

  • Analytics: They help you understand how users navigate your website, which pages are most popular, and how long visitors spend on different sections of your website.

Third-Party Cookies

Third-party cookies are created by domains other than your construction company's website. They are particularly powerful for tracking user behavior across multiple websites and platforms.

In construction marketing, they offer several advantages:

  • Cross-Site Tracking: They allow you to understand a potential client's journey across various construction-related websites, giving insights into their interests and needs.

  • Retargeting: If a user views your commercial construction services but doesn't inquire, third-party cookies enable you to show targeted ads to that user on other websites, keeping your services top-of-mind.

  • Audience Segmentation: They help create detailed profiles of users based on their browsing history, allowing you to target specific segments like commercial developers, architects, or facility managers with tailored marketing messages.

  • Ad Performance Measurement: Third-party cookies help track which ads lead to conversions, even when the conversion happens days or weeks after the initial ad view.

  • Frequency Capping: They can limit how often a user sees a particular ad, preventing ad fatigue and optimizing your marketing budget.

In Practice: A commercial property developer visits your website to view your portfolio of office building projects. First-party cookies might remember this preference, ensuring that office buildings are prominently featured on their next visit. Meanwhile, third-party cookies would allow you to show ads for your office construction services to this developer as they browse industry news sites, LinkedIn, or even general interest websites.

The Changing Landscape: With the impending degradation of third-party cookies, construction marketers will need to rely more heavily on first-party data and find new ways to achieve the targeting and measurement previously provided by third-party cookies. This might involve increased contextual advertising, partnerships with industry-specific platforms, and more robust CRM systems to make the most of direct client interactions.

Understanding the distinction between these cookie types and their roles in your marketing strategy is crucial as the digital advertising landscape evolves. It will help you adapt your approach to effectively reach and engage potential clients in the changing digital environment.

The Impact on Commercial Construction Advertising

The phase-out of third-party cookies will significantly affect how construction companies track and target potential clients online:

Loss of Conversion Data: The degradation of third-party cookies poses a significant challenge for tracking conversions in the commercial construction industry. These cookies allow marketers to capture a substantial portion of conversion data - potentially over 30% of all conversions. Without this capability, the impact on your marketing insights could be profound. Here's a deeper look at what this means:

Incomplete Customer Journey Tracking:

  • Currently: You can track a potential client's journey from seeing an ad on an industry news site to visiting your website, leaving, and returning days later to submit a project inquiry.

  • Post-Cookie: You might only see the final inquiry, missing the crucial data on what prompted their initial interest.

Attribution Challenges:

  • Currently: You can attribute a new commercial project lead to a specific ad campaign, even if the client interacted with multiple touchpoints over weeks or months.

  • Post-Cookie: You may need help determining which of your marketing efforts are most effective at generating quality leads.

Impact on ROI Calculation:

  • Currently: You can accurately track conversions, allowing for precise ROI calculations of your digital marketing campaigns.

  • Post-Cookie: The inability to track all conversions accurately could lead to underestimating the ROI, potentially resulting in misallocation of marketing budgets.

Long Sales Cycle Complications:

  • Currently: Third-party cookies help bridge extended timeframes in the long decision-making processes typical in commercial construction.

  • Post-Cookie: Connecting early-stage marketing touches to final conversions months later will become more challenging.

Loss of Cross-Device Insights:

  • Currently: You can track a property developer who sees your ad on their smartphone and later submits an RFP from their office computer.

  • Post-Cookie: These cross-device journeys may become invisible, fragmenting your understanding of the client's decision process.

Retargeting Limitations:

  • Currently: You can effectively retarget potential clients who've shown interest but haven't converted.

  • Post-Cookie: This ability will be significantly hampered, potentially reducing the effectiveness of nurturing campaigns.

Audience Segmentation Challenges:

  • Currently: You can create detailed segmentation (e.g., architects interested in sustainable design or developers focused on mixed-use projects).

  • Post-Cookie: Segmentation may become less precise, potentially leading to less personalized marketing efforts and lower engagement rates.

Impact on A/B Testing:

  • Currently: You can conduct accurate A/B testing of ad creatives or landing pages using comprehensive conversion tracking.

  • Post-Cookie: With partial data, it may become more challenging to make data-driven decisions about what resonates best with your audience.

Competitive Intelligence Gaps:

  • Currently: Third-party cookies provide insights into market trends and competitor activities.

  • Post-Cookie: Losing this data could give you a less clear picture of your position in the market.

Client Value Assessment:

  • Currently: You can often track the total value of a client from first touch to project completion.

  • Post-Cookie: Associating long-term client value with initial marketing efforts will take more work.

Reduced Algorithm Effectiveness: Advertising algorithms are crucial in the construction industry's digital marketing ecosystem. These algorithms help general contractors target architects, developers, and property managers. Similarly, they assist subcontractors in reaching general contractors who might need their specialized services. With the degradation of third-party cookies, these targeting capabilities may become less precise. The algorithms that currently help you pinpoint the right audience - whether you're a general contractor seeking clients or a subcontractor looking for partnerships - may need to be revised. This could lead to less efficient ad spend across the entire construction supply chain.

Privacy and Trust: While this change aims to protect user privacy, it challenges construction marketers to find new ways to personalize advertising without compromising potential clients' data.

Real-World Examples:

  • General contractors might find it harder to identify and target property developers planning new commercial projects.

  • Subcontractors may struggle to reach general contractors who frequently manage large-scale commercial builds.

  • Specialty concrete firms might see reduced accuracy in targeting general contractors working on infrastructure projects.

This change could necessitate a shift towards more contextual advertising and a stronger emphasis on first-party data collection for both general contractors and subcontractors, ensuring that marketing efforts remain targeted and cost-effective in the evolving digital landscape.

Why Commercial Construction Marketers Need to Act Now

Ignoring this change could put your construction firm at a competitive disadvantage. Here's why you should prepare:

Preserving Project Lead Data: Explore alternative tracking solutions, such as Google's Enhanced Conversions and Google Tag Manager, to avoid losing crucial data on potential construction projects.

Optimizing Marketing Budget: With less data, your marketing spend may become less efficient. Adapting to new tracking methods ensures your budget is used effectively, maintaining ROI on your construction marketing campaigns.

Maintaining Personalized Outreach: Personalized advertising enhances the experience for potential clients by delivering relevant content about your construction services. Without third-party cookies, you'll need to leverage first-party data to continue providing tailored experiences.

Staying Ahead in the Industry: Proactively addressing this change positions your construction firm as a leader in the new privacy-centric environment rather than lagging behind competitors.

What Steps Should You Take To Prepare For This Change?

Invest in robust first-party data collection strategies:

  • Enhance your website's data collection capabilities. Implement forms that capture valuable information about visitors' project interests, budget ranges, and timelines.

  • Create gated content (e.g., whitepapers on construction trends and case studies) that requires users to provide contact information to access.

  • Implement on-site behavior tracking to understand how visitors interact with your website without relying on third-party cookies.

Explore new technologies for conversion tracking that don't rely on third-party cookies:

  • Investigate server-side tracking solutions that can capture conversion data without relying on browser-based cookies.

  • Look into Google's Privacy Sandbox initiatives, such as the Topics API, which aims to provide interest-based advertising without third-party cookies.

  • Consider adopting Customer Data Platforms (CDPs) that can unify data from multiple sources and provide a holistic view of customer interactions. Salesforce's Customer Data Platforms (CDPs) are powerful tools that enable organizations to unify and leverage customer data from multiple sources, providing a comprehensive view of each customer. CDPs help businesses enhance customer experiences, improve marketing efficiency, and drive better business outcomes by facilitating real-time data processing, advanced segmentation, and personalized marketing.

  • Explore using first-party cookies combined with machine learning to predict user behavior and preferences.

Potentially shift focus to contextual advertising and intent-based marketing:

  • Develop a comprehensive keyword strategy that targets industry-specific terms and phrases relevant to your services. SEMrush, Ahref's, and Google Keyword Planner are excellent tools that we use to help develop keyword strategies for our clients.

  • Create content that aligns with the contexts where you want your ads to appear (e.g., articles about sustainable building practices if you specialize in green construction).

  • Utilize AI-powered contextual advertising platforms that can understand the nuances of construction-related content.

  • Implement intent-based marketing strategies that focus on capturing potential clients when they're actively searching for construction services. Use formats like blog posts, whitepapers, case studies, and FAQs to capture different stages of intent.

Enhance CRM systems to capture and utilize client interaction data:

  • Integrate your CRM with your website, email marketing platform, and other digital touchpoints to create a unified view of client interactions.

  • Implement lead scoring based on interactions and engagement to prioritize high-potential clients.

  • Use CRM data to create personalized marketing campaigns and communications.

  • Develop a system for regularly updating and maintaining client data to ensure accuracy and relevance.

Consider increasing direct engagement strategies to gather more first-hand data from potential clients:

  • Host webinars or virtual events on topics relevant to your target audience, using registration data to build your first-party database.

  • Increase your presence at industry trade shows and conferences, using these events to collect data directly from potential clients.

  • Implement a content marketing strategy that encourages engagement and data sharing (e.g., surveys, interactive tools, or calculators).  

  • Develop a robust email marketing strategy that provides value to subscribers while gathering more data about their interests and needs.

Invest in analytics and data analysis capabilities:

  • Build or expand your in-house data analytics team to make the most of the first-party data you collect.

  • Implement advanced analytics tools that can provide insights without relying on third-party cookies.

  • Regularly conduct data audits to ensure you collect and utilize the most valuable information for your marketing efforts.

Educate your team and clients:

  • Ensure your marketing and sales teams understand the implications of these changes and are prepared to adapt their strategies.

  • Communicate with your clients about your commitment to privacy and how these changes might affect their experience with your digital platforms.

Explore partnerships and second-party data opportunities:

  • To expand your data pool, consider forming data-sharing partnerships with complimentary businesses in the construction industry (e.g., material suppliers and architecture firms).

  • Investigate industry-specific advertising platforms that offer alternative targeting options.

Stay informed and agile:

  • Keep abreast of developments in privacy regulations and ad tech solutions.

  • Be prepared to pivot your strategies as new technologies and best practices emerge.

By taking these comprehensive steps, commercial construction firms can mitigate the impact of third-party cookie deprecation and potentially gain a competitive advantage in the evolving digital marketing landscape. The key is to start preparing, build strong, direct relationships with clients, and leverage the wealth of first-party data to create more personalized and effective marketing strategies.

The Future of Commercial Construction Advertising

This shift signifies a pivotal moment in digital advertising for the construction industry. It challenges marketers to innovate and adopt new strategies that respect privacy while still delivering effective, data-driven campaigns to reach architects, developers, and other potential clients.

As we approach this new era, staying informed and prepared is crucial for your construction business. Embracing enhanced conversion tracking and other advanced solutions will help ensure that your firm not only survives but thrives in a post-third-party cookie world.

The degradation of third-party cookies is a complex issue that requires immediate attention from commercial construction marketers. By understanding the implications and proactively adapting to new tracking methodologies, your construction firm can continue delivering powerful, personalized advertising experiences and maintaining a competitive edge in the ever-changing digital landscape.

The digital marketing landscape is shifting, but your construction firm doesn't have to be left behind. At Woodsmall Marketing Group, we're ready to help you navigate these changes and turn them into opportunities.

Ready to break ground on a new era of digital marketing for your construction firm? Contact Woodsmall Marketing Group today to get started.

1 view0 comments


bottom of page